Skip to main content
Hi! Sign in or registerDaily DealsBrand OutletGift CardsHelp & Contact
Sell
Watchlist
My eBay
  • Summary
  • Recently Viewed
  • Bids/Offers
  • Watchlist
  • Purchase History
  • Buy Again
  • Selling
  • Saved Feed
  • Saved Searches
  • Saved Sellers
  • My Garage
  • Sizes
  • My Collection
  • Messages
  • PSA Vault
Please sign-in to view notifications.
Loading...
eBay Home

Motors

Parts & accessoriesCars & trucksMotorcyclesOther vehicles

Clothing & Accessories

WomenMenHandbagsCollectible Sneakers

Sporting goods

Hunting EquipmentGolf EquipmentOutdoor sportsCycling Equipment

Electronics

Computers, Tablets & Network HardwareCell Phones, Smart Watches & AccessoriesVideo Games & ConsolesCameras & Photo

Business & Industrial

Modular & Pre-Fabricated BuildingsTest, Measurement & Inspection EquipmentHeavy Equipment, Parts & AttachmentsRestaurant & Food Service

Jewelry & Watches

Luxury WatchesWristwatchesFashion JewelryFine Jewelry

Collectibles & Art

Trading CardsCollectiblesCoins & Paper MoneySports Memorabilia

Home & garden

Yard, Garden & Outdoor Living ItemsTools & Workshop EquipmentHome ImprovementKitchen, Dining & Bar Supplies

Other categories

Books, Movies & MusicToys & HobbiesHealth & BeautyBaby Essentials
All BrandsAll CategoriesSeasonal Sales & Events
Advanced
Sponsored
Sponsored
Related:n172 old judget2061887 old judge psa1886 old judge1889 old judge1887 allen ginter1888 old judge1887 old judge king kelly1887 baseball cardsold judge baseball1887 old judge hof1887 old judge cap anson

Filter

    • Category

      • All
        • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
        • Sports Trading Cards
          • Selected categoryTrading Card Singles
          • Trading Card Sets
          • Trading Card Lots
        • Collectibles
        • Home & Garden
      • Authenticity Guarantee
      • Graded

        • Yes (482) Items (482)
        • No (188) Items (188)
        • Not Specified (8) Items (8)
      • Grade

        • 1 (64) Items (64)
        • 1.5 (128) Items (128)
        • 10 (4) Items (4)
        • 2 (54) Items (54)
        • 3 (61) Items (61)
        • 4 (47) Items (47)
        • 8 (5) Items (5)
        • 9 (2) Items (2)
      • Professional Grader

        • Beckett Vintage Grading (BVG) (2) Items (2)
        • Certified Sports Guaranty (CSG) (1) Items (1)
        • Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) (194) Items (194)
        • Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC) (287) Items (287)
        • Not Specified (194) Items (194)
      • Team

        • Atlanta Braves (1) Items (1)
        • Chicago Cubs (20) Items (20)
        • Cincinnati Reds (6) Items (6)
        • New York Giants (28) Items (28)
        • Philadelphia Phillies (15) Items (15)
        • Philadelphia Quakers (23) Items (23)
        • St. Louis Browns (22) Items (22)
        • St. Louis Cardinals (3) Items (3)
      • Features

        • Base Set (51) Items (51)
        • Collectors Edition (1) Items (1)
        • Insert (60) Items (60)
        • Limited Edition (3) Items (3)
        • Memorabilia (1) Items (1)
        • Parallel/Variety (5) Items (5)
        • Rookie (72) Items (72)
        • Serial Numbered (1) Items (1)
      • Manufacturer

        • Bazooka (1) Items (1)
        • Bowman (3) Items (3)
        • Panini (5) Items (5)
        • Signature Rookies (1) Items (1)
        • Topps (8) Items (8)
        • Upper Deck (1) Items (1)
        • Unbranded (1) Items (1)
        • Not Specified (602) Items (602)
      • Card Condition

        • Near Mint or Better (85) Items (85)
        • Poor (67) Items (67)
        • Very Good (39) Items (39)
        • Excellent (5) Items (5)
        • Not Specified (482) Items (482)
      • League

        • Major League (MLB) (170) Items (170)
        • Minor League Baseball (MiLB) (7) Items (7)
        • National Basketball Association (NBA) (3) Items (3)
        • National Football League (NFL) (1) Items (1)
        • National League (8) Items (8)
        • Not Specified (451) Items (451)
      • Player/Athlete

        • Bill Collins (5) Items (5)
        • Bill Olds (21) Items (21)
        • Buck Ewing (6) Items (6)
        • Dan Brouthers (6) Items (6)
        • Joe Judge (11) Items (11)
        • John Ward (11) Items (11)
        • King Kelly (13) Items (13)
        • Mike York (6) Items (6)
    • Price

      • Under $300.00
      • $300.00 to $540.00
      • Over $540.00
      $
      to
      $
      Please provide a valid price range
      Available inventory
      $0
      $1000+
    • Condition

      • Used (670) Items (670)
      • Not Specified (7) Items (7)
    • Buying Format

    • Item Location

      • Within25 mi
    • Shipping and pickup

      • Arrives in 2-4 days
      • Free Shipping
      • Local Pickup within25 miles
    • Show only

      • Free Returns
      • Returns Accepted
      • Authorized Seller
      • Completed Items
      • Sold Items
      • Deals & Savings

602 results for 1887 Old Judge

  • All
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • All Listings- Filter Applied
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • Any Condition- Filter Applied
  • Used
  • Not Specified
  • Default- Filter Applied
  • US Only
  • North America
  • Worldwide
  • Arrives in 2-4 days
  • Free Shipping
  • Best Match
  • Time: ending soonest
  • Time: newly listed
  • Price + Shipping: lowest first
  • Price + Shipping: highest first
  • Distance: nearest first
  • Gallery View
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
    derosnopS
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
    derosnopS
    • 1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge - Tobacco N172  Roger Connor #88-4 Skinned
      1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge - Tobacco N172 Roger Connor #88-4 Skinned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $547.00
      18 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Tue, 09:09 PM)
      +$7.90 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rhgeis65jk 100% positive (3.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Pat Deasley Skinned
      1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Pat Deasley Skinned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $56.00
      7 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Tue, 09:16 PM)
      +$8.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rhgeis65jk 100% positive (3.5K)
    • 1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge - Tobacco N172 Pete Gillespie Skinned
      1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge - Tobacco N172 Pete Gillespie Skinned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $40.00
      8 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Tue, 09:09 PM)
      +$7.90 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rhgeis65jk 100% positive (3.5K)
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge John Clarkson PSA 1
      1887 N172 Old Judge John Clarkson PSA 1
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,100.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.60 delivery
      Located in United States
      18 watchers
      derosnopS
      kesie8455 100% positive (82)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Tobacco Cards - U Pick - ORIGINAL - All SGC Graded
      1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Tobacco Cards - U Pick - ORIGINAL - All SGC Graded
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $430.00 to $3,955.00
      Buy It Now
      +$25.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      gfgcom 100% positive (4.8K)
    • California Brown 1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes "Bat in Left Hand at Side” SGC
      New ListingCalifornia Brown 1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes "Bat in Left Hand at Side” SGC
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $599.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.80 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      ogtus 100% positive (1.1K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Larry Twitchell SGC Cleveland Spiders variation pose 468-3
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Larry Twitchell SGC Cleveland Spiders variation pose 468-3
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $424.99
      Buy It Now
      +$5.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      10 watchers
      derosnopS
      2015fleemarkitfinds 100% positive (246)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1886 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball TOM DALY CHICAGO WHITE SOX  SGC 1   1500+ HIT
      New Listing1886 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball TOM DALY CHICAGO WHITE SOX SGC 1 1500+ HIT
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $595.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • Picked For You

      Top selling items from trusted sellers | Sponsored
        • 1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
          1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
          Opens in a new window or tab
          $3,000.00
          door2doortreasures (2,937) 99.5%
        • 1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 254-5 SGC A  $10,000 King Kelly Great Image!
          1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 254-5 SGC A $10,000 King Kelly Great Image!
          Opens in a new window or tab
          $16,889.00
          rhgeis65jk (3,537) 100%
        • 1886-1887 Old Judge N172 Old Hoss Radbourn #377-2 HOF SGC Authentic
          1886-1887 Old Judge N172 Old Hoss Radbourn #377-2 HOF SGC Authentic
          Opens in a new window or tab
          $12,899.00
          rhgeis65jk (3,537) 100%
          21 watchers
        • 1886-1887 Old Judge N172 Dan Brouthers #43-3 HOF SGC Authentic Incredible Image.
          1886-1887 Old Judge N172 Dan Brouthers #43-3 HOF SGC Authentic Incredible Image.
          Opens in a new window or tab
          $4,899.00
          rhgeis65jk (3,537) 100%
          13 watchers
    • GEORGE SCHOCH PSA 2.5 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CATCH HANDS HEAD HIGH 4175
      GEORGE SCHOCH PSA 2.5 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CATCH HANDS HEAD HIGH 4175
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $133.50
      4 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:47 AM)
      +$8.95 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Bill George New York Giants 184-2 National League SGC
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Bill George New York Giants 184-2 National League SGC
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $349.99
      Buy It Now
      +$5.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      2015fleemarkitfinds 100% positive (246)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 🏏 BASEBALL CARD  1887 Old Judge Goodwin Co. N172  TOM NAGLE Omahas SGC 10  ⚾🥎
      New Listing🏏 BASEBALL CARD 1887 Old Judge Goodwin Co. N172 TOM NAGLE Omahas SGC 10 ⚾🥎
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $549.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • GERMANY LONG 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS CUPPED #278-4c - PSA 3 VG - KANSAS CITY
      GERMANY LONG 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS CUPPED #278-4c - PSA 3 VG - KANSAS CITY
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $625.00
      Buy It Now
      +$3.60 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      the_lumber_company_sportscards 100% positive (7.9K)
      Authenticity Guarantee
    • HANDSOME BOYLE PSA 1.5 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE RIGHT ARM EXTENDED FORWARD 4178
      HANDSOME BOYLE PSA 1.5 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE RIGHT ARM EXTENDED FORWARD 4178
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $112.00
      2 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 02:02 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Mike Dorgan Skinned
      1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Mike Dorgan Skinned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $15.50
      4 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Tue, 09:08 PM)
      +$8.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rhgeis65jk 100% positive (3.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge N174 Mike Clearly SGC 6 POP ONE Hull Collection 2 Higher Gorgeous
      1887 Old Judge N174 Mike Clearly SGC 6 POP ONE Hull Collection 2 Higher Gorgeous
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $899.00
      or Best Offer
      +$13.24 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      yanksrule 100% positive (6K)
    • DICK CONWAY PSA AUTH 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE READY PITCH HANDS CHEST HIGH 4176
      DICK CONWAY PSA AUTH 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE READY PITCH HANDS CHEST HIGH 4176
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $133.50
      10 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:58 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HENRY ESTERDAY PR-FR 1
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HENRY ESTERDAY PR-FR 1
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,000.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      detroitsell 100% positive (60)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 Lev Shreve  PSA 5 - EX
      1887 Old Judge N172 Lev Shreve PSA 5 - EX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,040.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      deans_cards 100% positive (62.5K)Authenticity GuaranteeVisit deans_cards eBay Store!
    • FRED PFEFFER PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROWING RIGHT HAND NECK HIGH 179
      FRED PFEFFER PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROWING RIGHT HAND NECK HIGH 179
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      3 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:51 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • JOHN MORRILL PSA 2 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE PORTRAIT LOOKING RIGHT 4177
      JOHN MORRILL PSA 2 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE PORTRAIT LOOKING RIGHT 4177
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $152.50
      9 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:52 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 Billy O'Brien  PSA 1.5 - FAIR
      1887 Old Judge N172 Billy O'Brien PSA 1.5 - FAIR
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $385.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      deans_cards 100% positive (62.5K)Authenticity GuaranteeVisit deans_cards eBay Store!
    • TOM DALY PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS ON KNEES 4168
      TOM DALY PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS ON KNEES 4168
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      6 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 02:04 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JAMES MCQUAID Denver SGC 2.5 🥎⚾🥎
      New Listing1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JAMES MCQUAID Denver SGC 2.5 🥎⚾🥎
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $795.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • MIKE DORGAN PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROW LOOKING LEFT 4180
      MIKE DORGAN PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROW LOOKING LEFT 4180
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $45.00
      5 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:49 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Mike Mattimore Skinned
      1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Mike Mattimore Skinned
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $13.50
      3 bids · Time left2d 20h left (Tue, 09:19 PM)
      +$8.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rhgeis65jk 100% positive (3.5K)
    • JOHN MCGLONE PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROWING LEFT ARM EXTENDED 4171
      JOHN MCGLONE PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE THROWING LEFT ARM EXTENDED 4171
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $22.50
      4 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:50 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Cy Sutcliffe Looking At Ball By Bat PSA 3 P1315
      1887 N172 Old Judge Cy Sutcliffe Looking At Ball By Bat PSA 3 P1315
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $550.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      tbh39 100% positive (21.9K)
      Authenticity Guarantee
    • BOBBY WHEELOCK PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS CUPPED CHEST HIGH 4169
      BOBBY WHEELOCK PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE HANDS CUPPED CHEST HIGH 4169
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $67.00
      20 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 02:00 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • ⚾️ 1889 N172 Old Judge #42-1 Cal Broughton - SGC Pop 1 - Total Pop 2 - Rare Pose
      ⚾️ 1889 N172 Old Judge #42-1 Cal Broughton - SGC Pop 1 - Total Pop 2 - Rare Pose
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $448.85
      or Best Offer
      +$7.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      premiercardcollectors 100% positive (1.4K)
      Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY NNO VG N172 SGC A BASEBALL INDIANAPOLIS HOOSIERS
      1887 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY NNO VG N172 SGC A BASEBALL INDIANAPOLIS HOOSIERS
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $390.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      vintagecardco 99.9% positive (11K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
      1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $3,000.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      door2doortreasures 99.5% positive (2.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 Doogie Miller (Bat leaning) SGC 2
      1887 Old Judge N172 Doogie Miller (Bat leaning) SGC 2
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $550.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.89 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      corey1776 100% positive (524)Authenticity Guarantee
    • BUG HALLIDAY PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE (HOLLIDAY) HANDS AT BACK 4174
      BUG HALLIDAY PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE (HOLLIDAY) HANDS AT BACK 4174
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      3 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 02:01 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • WALT WILMOT PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CATCH HANDS THIGH HIGH 4172
      WALT WILMOT PSA 1.5 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CATCH HANDS THIGH HIGH 4172
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      9 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 02:03 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 Old Judge N172  Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
      New Listing1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,395.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Sid Farrar #153-4 SGC 1
      1887 N172 Old Judge Sid Farrar #153-4 SGC 1
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $300.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      stevy187 100% positive (2.7K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Thomas Flanigan Pitch, L/Foot Off Ground PSA Authentic
      1887 N172 Old Judge Thomas Flanigan Pitch, L/Foot Off Ground PSA Authentic
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $374.99
      Buy It Now
      +$4.95 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      memorylaneinc 100% positive (22.8K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • ⚾🚬 1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JOE SOMMER BALTIMORES SGC 3.5 VG +
      New Listing⚾🚬 1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JOE SOMMER BALTIMORES SGC 3.5 VG +
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,195.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)
    • ELMER CLEVELAND PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BAT HELD NEARLY HORIZONTAL 4173
      ELMER CLEVELAND PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BAT HELD NEARLY HORIZONTAL 4173
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      12 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:48 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge 182-6 pose Emil Geiss Portrait  SGC A - Chicago Cubs Pitcher
      1887 N172 Old Judge 182-6 pose Emil Geiss Portrait SGC A - Chicago Cubs Pitcher
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $425.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      14 watchers
      derosnopS
      tiger8mush 100% positive (1.8K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge 254 Mike King Kelly SGC Authentic Bat at Ready
      1887 N172 Old Judge 254 Mike King Kelly SGC Authentic Bat at Ready
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $3,999.95
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      19 watchers
      derosnopS
      cardboardcloud 99.9% positive (7.8K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • BILL WILL GLEASON CURT WELSH PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE 4167
      BILL WILL GLEASON CURT WELSH PSA 1 (MK) 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE 4167
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $102.50
      2 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:59 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 🥎🥎 1887  1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG ⚾⚾
      New Listing🥎🥎 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG ⚾⚾
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $895.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 -  Lev Shreve Trimmed/Cut Poor Condition
      1887 Old Judge N172 - Lev Shreve Trimmed/Cut Poor Condition
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $179.49
      or Best Offer
      +$4.80 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rubio1973 100% positive (1.5K)
    • ⚾⚾ 1887  1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card BUCK WEST Minneapolis SGC 3 VG 🏏🏏
      New Listing⚾⚾ 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card BUCK WEST Minneapolis SGC 3 VG 🏏🏏
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $995.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887-90 Old Judge N172/Gypsy Queen REPRINT: Dan Brouthers, Detroit Wolverines
      1887-90 Old Judge N172/Gypsy Queen REPRINT: Dan Brouthers, Detroit Wolverines
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $3.95
      Buy It Now
      +$1.25 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      thebaseballhobbyist 100% positive (33.8K)
    • 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card GEORGE PINKNEY OUTDOORS BROOKLYNS SGC 1.5
      New Listing1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card GEORGE PINKNEY OUTDOORS BROOKLYNS SGC 1.5
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $895.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card CY SUTCLIFFE Clevelands  SGC 5 EX
      New Listing1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card CY SUTCLIFFE Clevelands SGC 5 EX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,395.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Owen Patton Throw Minneapolis (min size) BXRD 105
      1887 N172 Old Judge Owen Patton Throw Minneapolis (min size) BXRD 105
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $350.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.25 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      trepidation34 99.9% positive (26.2K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card DAD CLARKE Chicago SGC 4 VG/EX
      New Listing1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card DAD CLARKE Chicago SGC 4 VG/EX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,295.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • BILLY CROWELL PSA 1 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CLEVELAND PITCHER RIGHT ARM EXTENDED 170
      BILLY CROWELL PSA 1 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CLEVELAND PITCHER RIGHT ARM EXTENDED 170
      Opens in a new window or tab
      MC SPORTS CARDS IS ACTIVELY ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
      New (Other)
      $100.00
      5 bids · Time left3d 1h left (Wed, 01:47 AM)
      +$5.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      mc_sportscards 99.9% positive (125.5K)
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Co. Baseball Card BILL GEORGE New Yorks  SGC 60 5 EX
      New Listing1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Co. Baseball Card BILL GEORGE New Yorks SGC 60 5 EX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,395.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • RARE BASEBALL UMPIRE CARD 1887 Old Judge N172 WALLACE FESSENDEN SGC 4.5 VG/EX
      New ListingRARE BASEBALL UMPIRE CARD 1887 Old Judge N172 WALLACE FESSENDEN SGC 4.5 VG/EX
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,500.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE MOUSE GLENN NNO FAIR N172 SGC A BASEBALL SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS
      1887 OLD JUDGE MOUSE GLENN NNO FAIR N172 SGC A BASEBALL SIOUX CITY CORN HUSKERS
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $420.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      vintagecardco 99.9% positive (11K)
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DUKE P. MINNEAPOLIS POOR
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DUKE P. MINNEAPOLIS POOR
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $250.01
      Buy It Now
      +$6.25 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rcs1958 99.7% positive (12.2K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 Danny Richardson  SGC 1.5 - FAIR
      1887 Old Judge N172 Danny Richardson SGC 1.5 - FAIR
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $320.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      deans_cards 100% positive (62.5K)Authenticity GuaranteeVisit deans_cards eBay Store!
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Joe Horning (Hornung) Bat Out-Boston PSA 2
      1887 N172 Old Judge Joe Horning (Hornung) Bat Out-Boston PSA 2
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $990.00
      or Best Offer
      +$4.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      oldshoebox 100% positive (1.4K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card FRED PFEFFER Chicago White Sox SGC 70 5.5 EX+
      New Listing1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card FRED PFEFFER Chicago White Sox SGC 70 5.5 EX+
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,495.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William "Dad" Clarke Chicago White Stockings SGC #77-5 RARE
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William "Dad" Clarke Chicago White Stockings SGC #77-5 RARE
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $449.99
      Buy It Now
      +$5.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      2015fleemarkitfinds 100% positive (246)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Old Judge N172 George Gore  SGC 3 - VG
      1887 Old Judge N172 George Gore SGC 3 - VG
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $600.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      deans_cards 100% positive (62.5K)Authenticity GuaranteeVisit deans_cards eBay Store!
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE N172 P. GUS KROCK VINTAGE CHICAGO BASEBALL CARD FLAWS GOOD MINUS
      1887 OLD JUDGE N172 P. GUS KROCK VINTAGE CHICAGO BASEBALL CARD FLAWS GOOD MINUS
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $289.99
      Buy It Now
      +$7.50 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      rcs1958 99.7% positive (12.2K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY BASEBALL CARD CATCH HANDS INDIANAPOLIS PSA 3
      New Listing1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY BASEBALL CARD CATCH HANDS INDIANAPOLIS PSA 3
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $995.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      caljeff 100% positive (22.9K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge Hardy Richardson Bat over r/shoulder Boston PSA 2  BXRD 41 *
      1887 N172 Old Judge Hardy Richardson Bat over r/shoulder Boston PSA 2 BXRD 41 *
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $1,200.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.02 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      trepidation34 99.9% positive (26.2K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • ⚾️ 1886-87 N172 Old Judge 117-1 Rare Portrait - Dell Darling - Chicago SGC Rare
      ⚾️ 1886-87 N172 Old Judge 117-1 Rare Portrait - Dell Darling - Chicago SGC Rare
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $598.89
      or Best Offer
      +$7.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      premiercardcollectors 100% positive (1.4K)
      Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William Schenkel Milwaukee Western Assoc SGC pose 401-3 RARE
      1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William Schenkel Milwaukee Western Assoc SGC pose 401-3 RARE
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $349.99
      Buy It Now
      +$5.99 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      2015fleemarkitfinds 100% positive (246)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 193-1 Gleason Portrait SGC A - King Kelly print anomaly
      1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 193-1 Gleason Portrait SGC A - King Kelly print anomaly
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $2,975.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      tiger8mush 100% positive (1.8K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 Allen & Ginter - N28 R.L. Caruthers SGC 2 (GOOD)
      New Listing1887 Allen & Ginter - N28 R.L. Caruthers SGC 2 (GOOD)
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $300.00
      0 bids · Time left6d 21h left (Sat, 10:13 PM)
      $800.00
      Buy It Now
      +$8.75 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      andrewprops 100% positive (163)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 N172 Old Judge #425-5 Germany Smith – Throw Right Hand Chin High - GD
      1887 N172 Old Judge #425-5 Germany Smith – Throw Right Hand Chin High - GD
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Pre-Owned
      $385.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.95 delivery
      Located in United States
      Free returns
      derosnopS
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      tonyetrade 100% positive (16.6K)
      Authenticity GuaranteeVisit tonyetrade eBay Store!
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE BRADLEY VG BATTING LOOKING AT BALL N172 SGC A SIOUX CITY
      1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE BRADLEY VG BATTING LOOKING AT BALL N172 SGC A SIOUX CITY
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $480.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      vintagecardco 99.9% positive (11K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • 1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE PINKNEY TEAM NAME BATTING N172 SGC 1 BROOKLYN BRIDEGROOMS
      1887 OLD JUDGE GEORGE PINKNEY TEAM NAME BATTING N172 SGC 1 BROOKLYN BRIDEGROOMS
      Opens in a new window or tab
      New (Other)
      $312.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.00 delivery
      Located in United States
      derosnopS
      vintagecardco 99.9% positive (11K)Authenticity Guarantee
    • Tell us what you think- opens in new window or tab
    • Results Pagination - Page 1

      1. 1
      2. 2
      3. 3
      4. 4
      5. 5
      6. 6
      7. 7
      8. 8
      9. 9
      10. 10
      Items Per Page
      • 120Items Per Page
      • 240Items Per Page

    Related Searches

    • n172 old judge
    • t206
    • 1887 old judge psa
    • 1886 old judge
    • 1889 old judge
    • 1887 allen ginter
    • 1888 old judge
    • 1887 old judge king kelly
    • 1887 baseball cards
    • old judge baseball
    • 1887 old judge hof
    • 1887 old judge cap anson

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice